Healthy Homemade Eggnog Ice Cream

Try this easy, healthier homemade eggnog ice cream without an ice cream maker and with no refined sugar!

Eggnog Ice Cream | Easy homemade healthy eggnog ice cream without an ice cream maker and with no refined sugar! | A Sweet Pea Chef

Eggnog floods our home during the holidays.

As soon as you can purchase it at the stores (usually the day after Halloween, in case you’re curious), Dustin and the kids basically become zombies for it.

They want it with breakfast, snacks, dinner, and as a dessert.

To be honest, it’s a little insane.

So, after I saw all the ingredients on the back of a store-bought eggnog carton a few years back, I decided I would make it from scratch so we could control what we were consuming.

Turns out: Homemade eggnog is AMAZING.  It’s delicious, thick, creamy, and even better than store-bought, if you can believe it.

With your own homemade eggnog recipe in hand, you can make anything from eggnog lattes to eggnog ice cream.  The creamy holiday cheer is endless!

Better yet: It just requires 6 simple ingredients that you probably already have!

If you’ve never tried or never heard of eggnog before, you might wonder what is eggnog and why we love it so much. Well, it’s a drink often enjoyed during the holidays, especially Christmas, in Canada and the United States.  It’s very thick, sweet, and dense, and has spices from cloves, cinnamon, and nutmeg.  Sounds amazing, right?

Separated ingredients ready to make the homemade eggnog ice cream, including egg yolks, whole milk, vanilla, pure maple syrup, cinnamon, nutmeg, and whole cloves.

HOW TO MAKE HOMEMADE EGGNOG ICE CREAM

Instead of the tedious task of tempering the egg yolks that is often required to make eggnog, I’ve realized there’s a MUCH EASIER way for how to make eggnog from scratch —> cook the eggs to be safe to consume by just blending it all together and heat through!

As for the eggnog ice cream recipe, turning eggnog into ice cream seriously couldn’t be any easier.  There are a few ways you can do this, which I’ve listed below:

  • pouring the chilled eggnog directly into a 9×5 loaf pan and freezing (this is how this recipe is made);
  • using an ice cream maker to churn the eggnog into ice cream;
  • using a popsicle mold to make eggnog ice cream popsicles.

Each way of turning eggnog into ice cream makes for a slightly different texture. All delicious.

I like to use whole milk for the eggnog because it makes it deliciously creamy and rich, plus you get all the benefits of using whole milk, but you can use whichever milk you prefer.

Overhead of the blender that includes whole milk, egg yolks and other seasonings that will then be cooked and turned into eggnog ice cream.

IS EGGNOG GOOD FOR YOU?

No Winter holidays without eggnog. That seems to be the rule in my house and I think most of you can relate. But… is eggnog good for you?

Typically, eggnog is made with…

  • whole milk
  • sugar
  • heavy cream
  • eggs
  • and some type of liquor – usually brandy, rum or bourbon.

Because it’s made with milk, eggnog is rich in calcium and other minerals including magnesium and phosphorus but also vitamin D and vitamin A. Still, eggnog is not that good for you.

The silver lining is – you can make healthy eggnog if you want.

How to make eggnog healthy:

  1. replace full-fat milk with skimmed milk or try my dairy-free eggnog recipe;
  2. add more milk and skip the heavy cream or condensed milk;
  3. substitute maple syrup or raw honey for sugar.

Sauce pan filled with the homemade eggnog to cook the eggs before turning into eggnog ice cream.

MAKING NON-ALCOHOLIC EGGNOG

Typically, eggnog is made by combining egg, milk, sugar, and spices, heating it together, and then chilling it.  Oftentimes, rum, bourbon, or brandy are added to eggnog to make it an alcoholic beverage, though this recipe is non-alcoholic.

While many people like to add alcohol to their eggnog, that’s not a big favorite in our house, since Dustin doesn’t drink alcohol and we often share it with the kiddos.

If you’re wanting to keep the liquor out and make non-alcoholic eggnog, the good news is you don’t have to do a thing different with this recipe.  You can just make this recipe as written and it will be non-alcoholic eggnog ice cream.

If you’re wanting to add in some alcohol, wait until it’s fully chilled to add it in.

Two servings of eggnog ice cream, each with two scoops, and topped with ground cinnamon.

HOW TO MAKE ICE CREAM WITHOUT AN ICE CREAM MAKER

You don’t need an ice cream maker to make eggnog ice cream. In fact, you can make any type of homemade ice cream without an ice cream maker if you want. Here’s how to make ice cream without an ice cream maker:

  • you can use a loaf pan or an airtight container to freeze the eggnog ice cream until it’s creamy and thick like I did for this homemade eggnog ice cream;
  • you can freeze the ice cream in a popsicle mold to make eggnog popsicles.

Simple, easy, no stress, and delicious results.

However, if you want your homemade ice cream to have the same smooth texture as an ice cream made with an ice cream maker, you can use the freeze & stir method:

  1. freeze the homemade ice cream for 45 minutes in an airtight container or a freezer-safe container covered with plastic wrap;
  2. remove from the freezer and stir with a spatula;
  3. return to the freezer for another 30 minutes;
  4. repeat the process of stirring and freezing for approximately 3 hours or until the homemade ice cream is completely frozen.

Two scoops of eggnog ice cream, ready to serve, and next to a container of homemade eggnog.

WHAT TO REPLACE SUGAR WITH IN ICE CREAM

To make delicious but healthy eggnog, you have to find a sugar substitute that works well in eggnog and eggnog ice cream. You can replace sugar with:

  • pure maple syrup, like I did in this eggnog ice cream;
  • if you’re not a big fan of maple syrup or you don’t like the taste, you can use raw honey to replace sugar.

Hand scooping some of the homemade eggnog ice cream that is topped with ground cinnamon and is next to whole cloves.

HOW LONG DOES HOMEMADE ICE CREAM LAST?

When it comes to ice cream, I’d say the fresher it is, the better it tastes. But you can definitely store ice cream in the freezer if you want.  I mean…it IS frozen, after all.

How long does homemade ice cream last for in the freezer? For approximately 2 weeks. If and only if you can make it last that long without eating it, of course.  While it won’t spoil after that point, it will start to harden and lose its flavor.

Two servings of homemade eggnog ice cream along with two spoons, cinnamon sticks, and whole cloves.

3 MORE HOMEMADE ICE CREAM RECIPES

You learned how to make eggnog ice cream and I think it’s only fair if I show you how to make ice cream from scratch with other flavors. Are you on board? I have 3 ice cream recipes that cannot wait to be in your freezer. All of these ice cream recipes are rich and creamy, and quick and easy to make. And totally delicious, of course!

Enjoy a dish tonight!

4 from 1 vote
Eggnog Ice Cream Square Recipe Preview Image
Eggnog Ice Cream
Prep Time
5 mins
Cook Time
10 mins
Total Time
3 hrs 15 mins
 
Easy homemade healthy eggnog ice cream without an ice cream maker and with no refined sugar!
Categories: Frozen, Ice Cream, Sweet Treat
Difficulty: Easy
Keyword: egg nog ice cream, eggnog ice cream, eggnog ice cream recipe
Servings: 6
Calories: 188 kcal
Author: Lacey Baier
Ingredients
  • 4 cups whole milk (or milk of choice)
  • 6 egg yolks
  • 2/3 cup pure maple syrup
  • 1 tsp ground nutmeg
  • 1 1/2 tsp ground cinnamon
  • 1 tbsp whole cloves
  • 1/2 tsp pure vanilla extract (optional)
Instructions
  1. In a blender, add the milk, egg yolks, pure maple syrup, ground nutmeg, and ground cinnamon, and then blend together for a minute until smooth.
  2. Pour this mixture into a sauce pan or deep pot, and then add the whole cloves, and heat over medium heat.

  3. Cook the eggnog for about 8-10 minutes until it starts to thicken and slowly cook the eggs. It will be frothy at first.  (We want the mixture to get hot, but not to simmer or boil. If it gets close to boiling, you can temporarily remove from the heat.)

  4. Strain the mixture using a fine mesh strainer to remove the cloves and any other bits.  You can stir in the optional vanilla extract at this time.

  5. Pour the strained mixture into a 9x5 loaf pan, and freeze until thick and creamy, like soft-serve ice cream, about 6-8 hours.

  6. When ready to serve, remove from freezer and let soften for about 10 minutes.

Recipe Video

Nutrition Facts
Eggnog Ice Cream
Amount Per Serving (0.5 cup)
Calories 188 Calories from Fat 69
% Daily Value*
Fat 7.7g12%
Saturated Fat 3.8g19%
Cholesterol 139.4mg46%
Sodium 69.2mg3%
Carbohydrates 27.8g9%
Fiber 0.4g2%
Sugar 19.3g21%
Protein 6.3g13%
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet.

This post contains affiliate links for products I use regularly and highly recommend.

Lacey Baier

Hey y’all, I’m Lacey Baier and I’m so glad you’re here! I’m a healthy lifestyle influencer and the creator of this clean-eating blog and YouTube channel, A Sweet Pea Chef. My recipes have been published on Food Network, Good Morning America, FoxNews, Tastemade, Fitness Magazine, and much more. I live in Dallas, Texas with my husband and four kiddos. Let’s get started!

4 thoughts on “Healthy Homemade Eggnog Ice Cream

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Recent Content